Here's what people have said about the workshop they experienced:
From the workshop at Maynard High School, March 2023:
I think I went into it looking to make smart, sophisticated, unique comments on it, but now I think the best comments come from a place of embracing what we don’t know.
I was able to understand more based on the feedback others brought up.
From the workshop at Fitchburg State University, March 2022:
Each time I listened, I was able to hear something different, or apply another student’s understanding each time.
I like how it encouraged thinking in layman’s terms.
I liked the professor’s enthusiasm towards the topic, really made me want to understand more.
Crowd-sourcing comments helped me see different angles and think about my own comments differently.
From the workshop at Illinois Wesleyan University, March 2021:
I really liked the time that we spent talking about the energy and the relationships that we heard in the piece, writing down different ideas and coming up with different things to look for or to be aware of in our next listen through the piece.
I really liked hearing everyone's different responses. It changed my perspective about the music.
I started looking at music as more than what I've trained for.
From the workshop at Wheaton College, November 2019:
Listening to the music more definitely helps. I began to picture it in more details and the structure started to form in my head.
I will think of music in wider ways.
I was able to think of music as more of an evolution (or progression.)
From the workshop at Illinois College, October 2019:
I learned to analyze things I wasn’t aware of before.
I liked hearing what everyone else thought of it.
I liked that what we said was exactly what was written on the board.
I liked learning the lesson of practicing not knowing.
From the workshop at Divergent Studio, June 2019 (a summer composition festival at Longy School of Music):
I was freed to enjoy the music while listening and not worrying about the “right answer”.
I made connections that made each event more interesting than on their own.
I liked that there was an attitude of no pressure and open-minded exploration.
The atmosphere was very relaxing, but during discussion time it was really energizing to hear everyone’s ideas and perceptions.
I enjoyed “crowd-sourcing” our ideas of what we heard. I think this was most important.
From the workshop at the Emerson College, Boston, MA. (filmmaking class):
It was interesting to hear how others heard the music, it made me listen with a different ear each time we listened again.
Hearing the energy others felt from the piece changed the way I understood the music and my own reactions to it – really a beautiful way to learn.
I really loved the drawings of what people mentioned in class. Being able to have a visualization of sounds helped us form a consensus on the piece.
I really enjoyed the facilitation! It was great how affirming John was. I also liked the shared listening experience.
From the workshop at the Greater Boston Zen Center, Cambridge, MA.:
I loved that being “the expert” simply means you must be even more open-minded in all walks of life.
I appreciated how open the teacher was to everyone’s comments.
(What I liked best was) the sense of community that developed as a result of the discussion – the “sound haven”.
I was very grateful for the respect you engendered amongst the group.
From the workshop at University of North Carolina-Greensboro School of Art:
Sympathy, compassion. Deep thought. I got a moment of peace, an opportunity to listen.
I like that we get everyone’s opinion. There’s no right or wrong.
The workshop allowed me to slow down and focus on singular elements — this helped me to pay attention to the repetitions in energy and sounds.
I liked the pacing of the workshop. I loved the music and listening to it repeatedly was a real pleasure. It was an opportunity to listen more than I usually get the chance.
(What I liked best was) listening to the same piece several times — letting our teeth sink into the feelings and the sounds, letting it sit for a long time.
I seemed to get to know it more and more each time I listened. I experienced it differently at each listening but felt I had a sense of the overall structure and development by the last listening.
(The most important thing I got was) the realization of how much is truly missed from just listening once. Also that other people’s narratives and feelings can change what I hear as well.
From the workshop at University of North Carolina-Greensboro School of Music (graduate and undergraduate composers):
I realized that a lot of people would relate what they heard to something else they know rather than simply observe what actually happened.
I was able to understand the form of the piece much better as a result of the workshop.
I started listening more for elements that seemed “obvious” at first and it began to feel more intentionally constructed the longer I listened.
I found a deeper connection to the real foundational characteristics of the music.
It encouraged listening to things I might not otherwise hear. It also emphasized sound over notation.
The concept and idea of allowing myself to “not know anything” and come into music just listening, engaging, and reflecting over what I find.
The need to let go of what you think you should know to be able to listen.
From the workshop at Salem College School of Music, Winston-Salem, NC (graduate and undergraduate music majors):
I liked listening multiple times to the piece.
I liked how the listening was a community effort.
The piece’s structure gradually emerged as I listened more.
From the workshop at Davidson College Presbyterian Church (DCPC), Davidson, NC:
More enjoyable, listenable with familiarity. Like knowing a complex friend.
Different perspective - especially with multiple participants and technical explanation.
Empowering the novice - or making the novice feel at home and capable. Beginner's mind welcomed and honored.
From the workshop at Divergent Studio, June 2018 (a summer composition festival at Longy School of Music):
It allowed me to take many steps back from my usual mode of listening.
Being able to step back from everything we know as musicians is very valuable, and helps to hear music from an audience perspective.
I like the attitude of staying engaged, which I think at times lacks in the western classical world.
From the workshop at The Laurels at Highland Creek (an assisted living facility outside Charlotte, NC):
What sounded initially like opposing/contrasting sounds developed into a more synchronized event.
Change in my understanding of "the nothing" to the appreciation of his style.
The speaker was entertaining and engaging with the audience.
From the conference, Contemplative Practices for 21st Century Higher Education, Chapel Hill, NC:
Sense of community after just 45 minutes.
I feel as though I have entry into the music now. I want to listen more.
I love the template... this template of contemplative listening seems full of so much potential.
From the workshop at Food For Thought, Follen Church in Lexington, MA:
The challenge to engage actively, even though I didn’t verbalize much, caused me to think about what was going on and define it in my head, thus opening me to greater understanding.
Much greater depth and dimensionality as a result (of the workshop).
Loved it!
From the inaugural workshop at the Community Music Center of Boston:
I liked how it was entirely directed by the audience – our contributions were what directed the workshop. I also liked how we listened to the piece many times to develop our understanding.
At first listen, prior to hearing others’ comments, there didn’t seem to be that much of a concrete meaning or changes. With more listens, a stronger sense of the work became clear.
(I liked most the) shared discussion and repeated listening, and (John)’s ability to get more and more thoughts out of people and being very supportive of answers.
I liked how many people contributed with many different ideas.
It was interesting that we were able to verbally create a diagram of the piece.
(I liked most the) shared experience of the music.